
photo courtesy of Erin Ash Sullivan
Album Review of Erin Ash Sullivan: Signposts and Marks
Erin Ash Sullivan serves up an excellent folk music album with Signposts and Marks. The music bed is full and rich, moreso than many folk records, providing a collection of songwriter-driven storytelling songs that can appeal to a broader audience than the more simply-produced acoustic singer-songwriter fare with which she shares a genre.

image courtesy of Erin Ash Sullivan
Erin’s voice is strong, emotive, and varied – she’s a heckuva singer even without the “hyphen-songwriter” attached. But she’s also quite a lyricist, utilizing relatably descriptive phrasing to paint pictures that make an unusually broad range of topics come to life on this record.
Erin opens with “Goat on a Stone Wall,” a song whose twangy-picking opening slides into one of the more typically rich-folk sounding songs on the record. But it also suggests this record is something a little different than you might have initially expected, carrying quite a bit of tempo throughout, showcasing an impressive vocal range, volume variance, and nimble phrasing.
“Rest Stop Bird,” next, features a semi-haunting chord pattern that reminds me a little of a Shawna Caspi song, especially early on, as it uses the imagery of a bird at a rest stop to convey some deeper thoughts, pleasantly, and catchily.

photo courtesy of Erin Ash Sullivan
“Baltimore” is worth noting, as it’s an exceptionally soulful number, but especially because it’s one of those songs you’ll be sure you’ve heard before. This has gotta be a cover, right? Nope. Instant classic. Some of my favorite lyrics on the entire record, in fact, come in this song: “‘Cause it’s the loved ones that take it the hardest when the actors stop reading their lines. When there’s a twist in the plot, whether they like it or not, all along they’ve been seeing the signs.” There’s so much packed in there, particularly within the context of the song, but no, I’m not going to share more of this song’s lyrics in this review. You’ll have to see and hear for yourself.
“One Time I Stole a Book” is softly and, not surprisingly, confessional, sporting guitarwork that sounds a bit like rain softly hitting the window. It’s a song about Erin’s grandparents, wistfully touching upon life’s little moments, perhaps turning points, with the lyric “give us grace to know the signposts and the marks,” from which the album title is drawn. And yes, Erin explains why she stole the book.

photo courtesy of Erin Ash Sullivan
“Winter Walk” is musically off-kilter, suitably accompanying the more disturbing song content. Give a listen, and then again, and keep thinking to yourself, “the lyrics say what?” For one thing, “two sets of prints out and one set home.” But I must say no more. The songwriter might already suspect I know too much.
“Eat the Pie” is another favorite. It’s a playful, cheerful song about reaching for the brass ring, just going for it, all based on the songwriter’s “tiny voice inside [her] head calling out to [her], ‘Eat the pie! Eat the pie!'” You’ll be cheering for the “nerdy bookish weirdo who was cut from every team,” and your anticipation will be rewarded. Not just by the lyrics’ payoff; you’ll also be treated to not-quite-four-minutes of fun, creatively-worded, whimsical listening enjoyment, almost certainly ending with a smile on your face.

photo courtesy of Erin Ash Sullivan
“Don’t Want to Keep Score” is sweet, serene crooner’s waltz that belies its topic of the toxicity of arguments, if you stop swaying to the music long enough to notice the lyrics.
The final three songs are parent to child themed. “We Walk the Flats” is sweet song about the passage of time, though, of course, more about walking on the beach. “How It Should Be,” next, is also heartfelt and wistful. And the record closes with “Before You Go,” a slice-of-lifer about savoring moments.
The twelve tracks of Signposts and Marks are richly textured, lyrically clever songs, delivered by Erin via impressively rich musical arrangements and an exceptional vocal range. If you like singers or songs – and why are you reading a music blog if you don’t? – then you should give this record a listen.