Album Review of Robert Scheffler: Truce
Singer-songwriter Robert Scheffler‘s album Truce showcases the singer’s talent and versatility, as the songs cover a broad range of influences, all centered by Scheffler’s storytelling ability and his hoarse, emotional vocal delivery. His breadth of range and the depth of the imagery and circumstance reminds me in some ways of Billy Joel, though Scheffler has a distinct style of his own. Scheffler has a tone that’s reminiscent of some of my favorite rock ‘n roll singer-songwriters – a bit of It Comes in Waves-era Martin Briley in some spots – and a bit more singer-songwritery in others, more like blog favorite Davey O., but perhaps a bit grainier. And when he’s soft-rocking with a little more tempo, I hear a little Don Henley in there. I’d love to hear some of the people Scheffler reminds you of – I know there are other names out there that escape me, but stylistically, Scheffler’s sound is, while being distinct, also very familiar, easy to get comfortable with and enjoy. I know strumming soft rock isn’t an easy category to break huge in – it takes a song that really touches somebody, perhaps tied to a favorite movie scene – but this dude has as much talent as those who do get their big breaks, and he’s got some songs here that, with the right placement, would launch him into the world’s musical consciousness. Regardless, this is a cool disc you should hear, and if nothing else, it can be one of your favorite albums of this subgenre.
Album-opener “Excuse the Mess” sets the tone from the get-go, bright and summerly strumming with tunefully compelling vocals. While that first song is acoustic – honestly, I had to listen back, even after reading that it was acoustic, to be sure because the song has so much energy – the disc is mostly electric, and that begins with song two. Indeed, Scheffler goes a little more nostalgic – to the extent present-tense can be so – with “Hang On, Skyline.” Just the lyric, tempo, and subsequent guitar riff of the line “Hang on, skyline; hang on, moon; I’ll be there soon” is an earworm that’ll leave an impression on you. Both of these first two numbers push ahead steadily, compellingly, even working in some nifty guitarwork. “Basher,” which follows, has its energetic stretches, and its calling card is a crunchy, distorted guitar riff, but it also slows down when the lyrics call for a little more intimacy.
“All in Good Time” is a melancholic, emotionally sung ballad. “Where Do I Know You From?” is funky-pop-rock, with an opening that suggests it could be related to Peter Gabriel’s “Sledgehammer” before it slides into being a smoother mid-tempo rocker. Still, it’s got some edge in its arrangement and subtle flamboyance in the vocal delivery. Then it’s followed by the middle song of this 11-song collection, a soft number that’s mellowly reminiscent, the sonically and nostalgically regretful-sounding “Truce,” paying off with the lyric: “How much longer can I cry for the promise of a truce gone by?”
You’ll get some tempo back on “Carry On Without Me.” The vocals don’t, in fact, sound like Don Henley, except for a bit of an insistent edge, but this absolutely sounds like a song you’d hear Henley sing on one of his albums. Or, at least, a song you’d hear on the radio played alongside “The Boys of Summer” or “The Last Worthless Evening.” The energy amps up a little more, though still remains in the same sonic neighborhood, with the next track, “Blue Sky Mess.”
Then, just when you get into a whole mid-tempo soft rockin’ groove, Scheffler changes things up and goes full-on acoustic with one of the more memorable songs on the album, “I Don’t Love You Like I Should.” I mean, as much as I love the electric stuff, this might be the number that’d most easily reel in new fans because it’s just so dang cool. It sounds like something you’d hear on a Barenaked Ladies record – their weird, acoustic, uniquely catchy stuff – yet it somehow works on this album, almost entirely because of Scheffler’s identifiable vocals. And the nice turns of phrase in the lyrics, well, those would help this song work in just about any setting.
Before you settle in too much, though, a peppy drum beat and energetic strum greets you on “Punch Line,” a song whose beat, tempo, and rhythm make it a musical fraternal twin – or at least a close, best-pal cousin – of “Hang On, Skyline.” The second song of the record stylistically matching the second-to-last? It’s just one of those little things that ties this record together as a cool listening experience. For me, this is my singalong song on Truce. It gets me up to sing and dance every single time.
So how does a classic, mainstream-friendly soft rock singer-songwriter end an excellent record like Truce? With melancholy, of course. Duh! “We’re All Waiting” will end your listening experience with a sniffle.
Truce is a satisfying record, with so much lyrical depth and about as much stylistic variety as you can expect from a soft rock singer-songwriter’s album, simply an impeccable 11-song collection.





































