Album Review of Andrew Potter: Underwater Palace
Rhode Island-based singer-songwriter Andrew Potter draws upon a variety of influences on his album releases, the more recent of which is Underwater Palace. If this is your first encounter with Potter, you’ll experience a singer-songwriter who takes advantage of all the richness and full instrumentation and orchestration available in a studio setting. If this is your second encounter with a Potter recording, though, after his 2022 release I Haunt My Own House, you’ll know that he’s just as capable of delivering an intriguing, entertaining record in a more stripped-down setting, as well. That’s not to say the arrangements on I Haunt My Own House are thin. No, they’re complete, well-constructed multi-track compositions. It’s just that Underwater Palace is much more theatrical by comparison. Regardless, the neat thing about the comparison is that it proves Potter’s songs play well in a variety of arrangements – the dude’s simply a talented songwriter/performer.
Not that it’s a one-man show on Underwater Palace. Certainly not! Potter (piano, vocals, rhythm electric and acoustic guitars, accordion) is joined by talented bandmates Marty Ballou (bass), Mark Teixeira (drums), Mark Cutler (lead and slide guitar), and Rick Couto (percussion).
Potter opens Underwater Palace dramatically from the very start. First track “Lord, How It Come to Nothing?” begins with pianowork that’s a cross between symphonic and what you’d expect from an old west saloon in a movie. Then the vocals kick in, overenunciated and forcefully theatrical, as if being performed in a huge Broadway theater, without amplification, so the person in the last row can not only hear but understand each word, complicated by the fact that Potter’s delivery also bears a striking resemblance to that of a carnival barker giving a rare serious musical performance, trying to tone things down to be taken seriously as an artist and not entirely succeeding in escaping the carnival persona. The end result, for those of us listening to the song, is an extremely entertaining performance style, one that necessitates repeat listens to try to pay attention to the clever lyrics.
After that auspicious start, the album avoids any letdown, as track two, “Downing Street,” is one of my personal favorites. It showcases Potter’s capability as a storyteller, mixing an old-school piano bar, almost “Entertainer”-esque piano-playing style – not as fast-paced, obviously – with supporting guitarwork and expressive vocals to paint a picture of life on Downing Street.
By this point in the album, it’s clear Andrew Potter is a uniquely original talent with his emotive vocal style and almost carnival-meets-theater styled arrangements. And that’s just a start, as the songwriting paints attention-grabbing mental images, creating songs you want to listen to for both the musical stylings and the lyrical content. Worth noting, the lyrics on each song are credited to Wheeler Cole, while Potter is credited with writing the music. They’re a great songwriting partnership, and the crediting at least presents is as a well-matched Elton John-Bernie Taupin style partnership.
In any case, “Rainey Daze,” next, hints at vaudeville, while “Koala Bear” is written in an almost disjointed style, emphasizing the colorful lyrics in the verses while transitioning to a smooth, melodiousness for the chorus.
“Two Tents” does a great lyrical comparison between the religious revival and the circus – the two tents – as Potter’s arrangement and performance are both heavier and more forceful than most of the preceding songs while still remaining entertaining, ensuring that beyond the power of the music there’s also a strong connection to the humorous dichotomy in the lyrics.
“Seeking Renewal” uses playful pianowork and the vocal style of a grizzled world-weary character as the first-person storyteller, making life mistakes then “seeking renewal, so I can do it again.” As is a common theme, Potter’s music and delivery vary broadly within the piano-guitar-singer-creator role to match the sound to the lyrics. And the lyrics and sound are exceptionally creative and original.
“How Does Love Grow?” adds another arrangement style to the collection with swaying pianowork that sounds as if it could spring from a music box, well-matched to a playfully-worded song about life, aging, and looking back.
“Going Home” has a little folkier feel, though being piano-based rather than guitar-based gives it more dynamism that the typical folk number. Of course, Potter’s dynamic vocal delivery plays a role in that, too. The lyrics are worth listening to, too, encouraging travel much as Rick Steves might, with the payoff lyric “You won’t know who you really are ’til you see home from afar.”
The title track appears near the end of the record. “Underwater Palace” is pleasant but feels serious and dramatic, befitting its topic of sea levels rising. On this song in particular, Mark Cutler’s guitarwork helps guide the sound a little toward progressive rock.
The album closes with “Caribbean Sunrise,” a tropical swaying number that elicits the setting of a beach vacation thanks to the slide guitarwork driving the song, matching the lyrics.
Beginning to end, Underwater Palace is an enjoyable, theatrical, flamboyant collection of well-crafted songs delivered stylistically unlike much else you’ll hear anywhere. The songs are engaging and fun, while the production pays attention to every detail. Given the broad spectrum of Potter’s capabilities and musical visions, there’s plenty of variety on this record, making it an enjoyable repeat listen. If you’re a fan of songwriting, creative performances, and/or theatrical pop-rock with a bit of a progressive edge, you need to know about Andrew Potter, and you should give this record a listen.
Also, as I noted at the top, if you like more traditional folk-rock singer-songwriter fare – either in addition to or instead of more progressive musical arrangements – you may want to give Potter’s 2022 album I Haunt My Own House a few spins. They’re both great discs; I just chose to review the newer one.
