EP Review: Kim McClay – Worth It

photo by Myles Tracy (Smyleybird Studios); photo courtesy of One in a Million Media

EP Review of Kim McClay: Worth It

The song that’ll grab you right off the bat, “Velveteen Girls,” is, in fact, the first song on Worth It. That’s fortunate, as it’ll encourage you to keep coming back to this 5-song EP, and the rest of the songs will grow on you quickly after a few listens. Count on it!

Kim McClay surrounds herself with talented bandmates on her EP Worth It. McClay is joined by Dustin Beardsley (electric guitar), Trevor Brown (bass), and Jim Bloom (drums). The record is lyrically intricate with the engaging song structures you’d expect from an experienced singer-songwriter like McClay, except of course that her songs mostly kick ass like ’90s alt-rockers because, well, she’s that, too. Even so, the last couple of songs lean a little away from alt-rock and more toward the rockin’ singer-songwriter category, suggesting a breadth of performance skills that would make McClay as comfortable in an intimate performance setting as on a rock club stage.

image courtesy of One in a Million Media

“Velveteen Girls” is the most raucous, rowdy song on the album, at least beginning to end. An anthem championing women in the music industry – calling out some of the sexist crap they face in the business in the process – “Velveteen Girls” is an energetic, danceable rocker. Sung with a hint of a sneer (at times, more than a hint) atop a buzzy, dirty ’90s college rock club-worthy guitar buzz, this song is an absolute friggin’ repeat-playable romp. It’s be a favorite from the very first listen.

“Firefly” slows things down quickly. The vocal delivery during the verses reminds me of the jazzy vocals Dana Carmel delivered on several of my favorite songs from her album a few years ago. The rest of the song, though, is active, buzzing classic alt-rock fare, with McClay’s vocals rising in intensity, nearly reaching a wail by the end of the song, matching the ramp-up of the instruments.

photo by Eryn Leeann; photo courtesy of One in a Million Media

“Worth It,” next, serves up stylish strums and a bit of a herky-jerky rhythm in the verses, while the chorus has a more standard, clearer musical arrangement, with an energetic, almost cheerful guitar and vocal hook (if “dancing through chaos and dodging the salt in our tears” can be called cheerful). This song was a little slower to gain my attention than “Velveteen Girls,” but after a couple dozen listens, I’m no longer sure which is my favorite. So give this one a little time. And listen for the nuances; if I had, I’d have reach fanboy status for “Worth It” much sooner.

“So Close” changes the tone a little, serving up a Nashville singer-songwriter styled storytelling vibe. Not the country bit; no, there’s a little edgy to the guitar strum and an alt-pop atmospheric sound in the mix. It shows yet another side to McClay’s talents while also showing off a new side to Beardsley’s axework.

The EP ends softly with “Something Like Love.” It’s a 5-plus minute number that transforms from a soft singer-songwriter piece to a full-on, heavily instrumented emotional tour de force by the end. I think once you pass the five minute mark, you’re officially progressive rock, and in both instrumentation and arrangement, there’s a little nod to prog, though not really. More correct would be to say that it’s a big, powerful ending to a cool EP.

Singer-songwriter fans and ’90s-style alt-rockers are gonna dig this record. And with the strong songwriting, lyrics, and musicianship found on the Worth It EP, many of the rest of us will, too.

More Recently

Just a couple weeks ago, McClay released a short digital EP, Kim McClay (Live at Power Station), which features live performances of 3 of the songs on Worth It, so you may want to check that out, too. For those who’ve already hear Worth It and are just reading this review to see what I had to say about it, this new release is recent enough, it could still be news to you.